Proud Veteran-Owned Business Partner to The Purple Heart Foundation
For many veterans, the Compensation and Pension (C&P) exam is the most stressful part of the VA disability claims process. You wait for an appointment, drive to a facility you’ve never been to, and sit across from a stranger who holds your financial future in their hands.
You walk in ready to bare your soul about your PTSD, depression, or anxiety. Oftentimes, this is after years of delay due to stigma, ego, or military conditioning. But instead of a compassionate conversation, you get a 15-minute rushed appointment. The examiner barely looks up from their computer, cuts you off when you try to explain your worst days, or seems to lack basic knowledge of military culture. You leave the appointment feeling unheard, frustrated, and terrified that this one bad interaction has just tanked your entire claim.
If this sounds familiar, you are not alone. I’ve spoken with countless veterans who have had similar experiences. Luckily, a bad mental health C&P exam is a common hurdle, and it is not the end of the road. You have options, and you can fight back.
At VMHA, we help veterans navigate these exact situations every day. This comprehensive guide will walk you through exactly what to do if you’ve had a bad mental health C&P exam, how to report it, and how to override a negative opinion with stronger, private medical evidence.
Before you take action, it’s important to identify exactly why the exam was inadequate. A “bad” exam isn’t just one where you feel the doctor was unfriendly; it’s one where the examiner failed to follow VA regulations or clinical standards.
Here are the most common red flags of an inadequate mental health C&P exam:
If any of these happened to you, your exam may be considered “inadequate,” and you have grounds to challenge it.
Do not wait for your denial letter to arrive. You need to create a paper trail immediately. The moment you get to your car or get home, write down everything that happened.
This document is called a Memorandum for Record (MFR) using VA Form 21-438. It is a factual statement of what occurred during the exam.
What to include in your MFR:
Where to send it:
Upload this document to your VA claim file immediately via the VA.gov portal or QuickSubmit. This puts your complaint on the official record before a rater makes a decision.
You cannot effectively fight a bad exam if you don’t know what the doctor wrote. The examiner fills out a form called a Disability Benefits Questionnaire (DBQ). This document acts as the “scorecard” for your disability rating.
The examiner might have smiled to your face but checked the boxes for “mild” symptoms on the form. You need to see this report.
How to Request It:
Submit VA Form 20-10206 (Freedom of Information Act Request) to the VA. In the request section, specifically write: “I am requesting a copy of the C&P exam DBQs conducted on [Date] by [Contractor Name].”
If the exam was truly incompetent, you have the right to request a new one. This is not guaranteed, but it is worth trying.
Call the VA White House Hotline (1-855-948-2311) or the main VA number (1-800-827-1000). Tell the representative you want to file a formal complaint about your C&P exam and that you are requesting a “new examination based on an inadequate exam.”
Reference your Memorandum for Record. Be specific: “The examiner spent 10 minutes with me and refused to discuss my depression symptoms. This exam was inadequate to rate my disability.”
Reporting a bad exam is defensive. Getting an Independent Medical Opinion (IMO) is offensive. This is how you win.
The VA’s C&P examiner is just one doctor. Their opinion is not the final word. You have the legal right to submit your own private medical evidence that carries equal (or often greater) weight.
An IMO is a comprehensive expert report written by a private psychologist or psychiatrist who is not employed by the VA. Unlike the rushed C&P exam, an IMO provider at VMHA will:
When a VA rater looks at your file, they will see two reports:
The IMO provides the rater with the “qualifying medical evidence” they need to override the bad exam and grant your benefits.
If the bad exam leads to a denial, do not panic. You should now file a Supplemental Claim (VA Form 20-0995).
A Supplemental Claim allows you to say, “I have new and relevant evidence.”
By doing this, you force the VA to consider the new, better evidence. In many cases, the rater may accept the comprehensive IMO over the inadequate C&P exam.
Mental health claims are unique. Unlike a knee injury, where a doctor can look at an X-ray, which is indisputable, mental health cannot always be seen with the naked eye.
A bad C&P exam for PTSD often misses the invisible symptoms:
The VMHA Difference
At VMHA, our psychologists understand the VA rating criteria inside and out. We know that severity and frequency are what matter. Our assessments are designed to capture the full picture of your life—how your depression keeps you isolated, how your anxiety ruins your sleep, and how your PTSD impacts your family. We put this into clinical language the VA cannot ignore.
We’re for veterans who have done their research. They don’t want a cheap letter. And they don’t want to sacrifice their benefits. They need high-quality psychologists, ethical advocacy, and an experience they can trust.
Statistic: According to a report by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), denial rates for mental health claims remain high, often due to a failure to establish a clear link to service. Furthermore, the VA Office of Inspector General (OIG) has found that claims processors frequently fail to request necessary medical exams or overlook evidence, highlighting the critical importance of submitting your own comprehensive medical evidence, such as an Independent Medical Opinion, to provide the nexus that VA examiners may miss. GAO-19-125
Technically, yes, but it is risky. We generally recommend you attend all VA-ordered exams. If you skip it, the VA can deny your claim instantly. The best strategy is to attend the exam and upload it to your file beforehand. This forces the examiner to consider your private doctor’s expert opinion.
Not always, but it is possible. The rater usually follows the C&P examiner’s suggestion unless you provide stronger evidence to the contrary. That is why waiting and hoping is not a strategy—you must submit counter-evidence (an IMO) to tip the scale back in your favor.
An IMO is an investment in your future. While costs vary, think of it this way: a successful claim can yield thousands of dollars in tax-free income every month for the rest of your life. The cost of an IMO is a small fraction of the lifetime value of the benefits you earned. At VMHA, we offer transparent pricing so you know exactly what you are paying for—no hidden fees, no percentages of your back pay.
You served your country with honor. You should not have to fight on the home front just to get a fair medical evaluation. A 15-minute exam with a dismissive doctor does not define your reality, and it does not have to dictate your future.
If you’ve had a bad C&P exam, take action today. Report it, request your records, and most importantly, get the expert medical evidence you need to prove your case.
Ready to get an accurate, fair assessment?
At VMHA, our expert psychologists ensure our veterans don’t have to settle for less than they deserve. Our team is ready to hear your story and provide the high-quality Independent Medical Opinion you deserve. We don’t rush you, and we don’t check boxes without listening. We provide ethical advocacy and an experience you can trust.
Contact us today to schedule your consultation.
Email us at info@vmhaforvets.com or call us at 214-307-2198.
VMHA
